“I think a lot of investors forget that this was the hottest REIT asset class heading into 2020,” he said, when office vacancy rates were extremely tight, and investors flocked to the sector for its monthly payouts.
But post-pandemic, McNabb said he’s noticed pedestrian traffic in Toronto’s PATH system – an underground walkway network in the downtown core – is still very low on Mondays and Fridays in particular.
“The office isn’t dead, but I do believe it has changed,” he said.
The COVID-induced work-from-home shift has ravaged the office market as many employers re-evaluated their office footprint. Firms have also looked at reducing their real estate holdings as a way to rein in expenses to help cope with the current weaker economy.
“It is likely that 10% to 15% of demand has been permanently destroyed with (work-from-home) trends,” said Maria Benavente, vice-president and real estate-focused portfolio manager at Dynamic Funds.
“We expect it to continue to be a market of haves and have-nots,” she said.
A September report from Colliers Canada showed the national office vacancy rate rose to 14.1% in the third quarter last year, up from 13% in the third quarter of 2022.
Office vacancy rates have been rising for three and a half years and will likely continue to climb in the short term with remote working still prevalent, according to the report.
Meanwhile, average asking rents for offices neared a record high of $21.08 per square foot, driven mainly by the removal of older office buildings and landlords negotiating concessions beyond lower rent, the report said.
John Duda, Colliers’ president of real estate management services, Canada, said he expects a “slow uptick” in office space absorption by the end of 2024, but he’s not “anticipating a radical turnaround.”
Part of the issue is the disparity between what employers and workers want.
“What’s been preventing a more dramatic shift in back-to-the-office, it’s been the imbalance in the employment market,” Duda said in an interview.
“The employees have had a lot of power and that means they’re just not coming in and saying, ‘I won’t come in.’ But that is starting to shift and we’re noticing it particularly in the (downtown) cores; the busy level has picked up very significantly,” he said.
Units in Slate Office REIT, Allied Properties REIT, True North Commercial REIT and Dream Office REIT are all down between 625 and 85% since March 1, 2020.
Sentiment remains fairly negative on the sector and timing the recovery is difficult, said Benavente, pointing out how Calgary’s office market was still struggling to recover from the 2014 oil price collapse even before the pandemic.
“Office is a value investment – value requires patience and tolerance for volatility,” she said.
“We think there is some value; however, investors need to be selective and be laser-focused on balance sheet, liquidity and dividend coverage. We saw many office REITs being forced to cut their dividends, sometimes even twice.”
Slate Office REIT, for example, suspended its monthly distribution in mid-November to conserve cash. True North Commercial REIT slashed its monthly payout early last year.
Office REITs will do well when the economy begins to recover and businesses return to hiring mode, Benavente said. Banks also need to be willing to lend more freely to office landlords for activity to pick up in the sector.
McNabb said he’s still very cautious on the sector and wants to see vacancy rates improve. But he believes longer-term investors could start “picking away” at higher-quality companies, which could prove to be a good investment in time.
“Commercial real estate follows the simple economic rule of supply and demand – and currently supply is outstripping demand by a very wide margin,” McNabb said.